At 63, I looked at the Thanksgiving photo on my fridge and saw my mother.
A letter from a reader
At 63, I looked at the Thanksgiving photo on my fridge and saw my mother.
I have never written anything like this before, but my sister has asked me where I got my jacket three times in one weekend, and I am tired of typing out the answer. So here it is, the whole story, once.
It starts with a photo.
Last Thanksgiving my daughter Kate printed the family picture and put it on the fridge with two magnets shaped like lemons. Fourteen of us on the front steps. My grandsons in the middle, pulling faces. Don holding the dog.
And me, at the end of the row, in a gray fleece and a long beige tunic sweater that came down nearly to my knees.
I stood at the fridge with a dish towel in my hand and said out loud, to nobody, "When did I start dressing like my mother?"
How it happened
I knew exactly how it had happened, because I had been there for every step.
Every fall I bought something warm. And every fall, the warm thing was a little more shapeless than the one before. First the fleece, because it was soft. Then the long tunic sweaters, because they covered everything. Then a long navy coat the color of nothing, because the wind off the lake does not care how you look.
None of it was a mistake on its own. Each one was sensible. That was the whole problem. Put enough sensible things in one closet and you end up at the end of the row in the family photo, warm, comfortable and invisible.

The two things I tried first
I did try to fix it, and I suspect you have tried the same two things.
The first fix was the comfort aisle, only nicer. A better fleece. A more expensive long cardigan. The same shape in a better fabric. In the next photo, at my granddaughter's birthday in March, I looked exactly the same.
The second fix was the opposite. A young woman at the mall put me in a short, fitted, very fashionable jacket about as thick as a dish towel. I wore it to church once, in October. I sat through the whole service with my arms folded, and by the far end of the parking lot I could not feel my ears. It went to the back of the closet. The fleece came back out.
So that was my choice, as far as I could see. Warm and shapeless, or shaped and cold.
What I had wrong
Here is the part it took me sixty-three years to notice.
Fleece, quilting and long knits keep you warm with bulk. They puff out to trap the air, and anything that puffs out cannot follow your shape. So the warmer they get, the bigger and blurrier you look. That is not a failing in you. It is just how that kind of warm works.
There is another kind of warm, the kind my father's old herringbone overcoat had. It keeps you warm with weight. The weave is dense and brushed, so the cloth is heavy, and heavy cloth can be cut close to the body and still keep the fall wind off you. It does not have to puff out to work.
I did not have to choose between warm and shapely. I needed the other kind of warm.
Mine is the Evangeline
I found it this fall at a little shop in Newport, Rhode Island called Parker & Klein. Margaret Parker has dressed women there since 1999. She grew up above her father's alterations counter, and he taught her that clothes should fit the woman, not the other way around. You can feel that in the cut.
Mine is the Evangeline. Olive herringbone, dense and brushed, heavy enough to hold its own shape on the hanger. Deep cuffs and a front edge in a plush brown. A low stand collar instead of lapels. Two chest pockets with buttoned flaps, and engraved metal buttons.

The part that matters is the cut. It sits close to the body with seams that follow the waist, and nothing about it is boxy. On the back, a line of rust topstitching traces the panels. Nobody will ever see it from the front, and I love it anyway.
I wear it over a white shirt and dark jeans, the plainest things I own. It does not ask for anything else.

The weekend my sister wouldn't let it go
I wore it for the first time the weekend my sister Linda drove up from Indianapolis.
She noticed it in the driveway. She asked about it again at lunch, and once more on Sunday, which is how I came to be writing this.
That Sunday, a woman from church I have known for twenty years, who has never once said a word about my clothes, stopped me on the steps and asked where it was from.

And Don. Don has not commented on a single piece of my clothing since our twenty-fifth anniversary, and that was a dress I bought specifically so he would. On the way to the car he looked over and said, "That's a good jacket."
From Don, that is a sonnet.

I did not need a new wardrobe. I needed one jacket that did not look sensible.
Three things I've learned since
One. Warm does not have to mean big. Look for weight, not puff: a dense weave that holds its own shape.
Two. Wear it over the plainest things you own. A white shirt and jeans. When the jacket has something to say, nothing else needs to.
Three. Close to the body, never boxy. The cut is the difference between looking put together and looking put away.
The rest of the rack
The button on this page takes you to all ten blazers Margaret makes, so here are three I nearly bought instead.



If the Evangeline is not quite you, one of these will be.
About the price
I want to be plain about this, because it was the part that made me hesitate.
The Evangeline is $89.95. It was $299.95.
I have spent more than that on fleece over the years, and not one piece of it ever got me a "That's a good jacket."
The reason, as far as I can tell, is simple. After twenty-seven years in Newport, Margaret is moving the shop into a smaller space closer to her grandchildren. Half the room means half the racks, so this season's collection is not making the trip, so she is bringing the move together with Black Friday and starting early, and it has all been marked down. There is no catch that I have found.
I read the small print before I ordered, as I expect you are doing now. Shipping is free anywhere in the US, and you have thirty days to send it back if it is not what you hoped. That was enough for me.
What I would tell you if we were friends
If you were sitting at my kitchen table, next to that fridge, this is what I would say.
Go and stand in front of your closet. If the warmest things in it are also the most shapeless, you have not gotten old. You have just only ever been sold one kind of warm.
This year I will be in the middle of the photo.
Two practical things. The popular sizes go first. And there are ten blazers to choose from, so if the Evangeline is not yours, one of the others will be.
Susan
P.S. Linda has now asked for the website twice. I am sending her this page instead.

The Evangeline Jacket
XS · S · M · L · XL · 2XL · 3XL
$299.95 $89.95
- Dense, brushed herringbone with real weight to it
- Deep plush brown cuffs and front facing
- Low stand collar, two buttoned flap chest pockets
- Engraved metal buttons, worn closed or open
- Trim, shaped fit with seams that follow the waist
- Free US shipping · 30 day returns
The popular sizes go first.
Susan Hayes is 63 and lives outside Chicago with her husband, Don. She is not a fashion writer.
Parker & Klein · Free US shipping · 30 day returns
This page is an advertisement for Parker & Klein.
